A contextual approach to the admissibility of the state's forensic science and medical evidence

Edmond, Gary and Roach, Kent (2011) A contextual approach to the admissibility of the state's forensic science and medical evidence. University of Toronto Law Journal, 61 (3). pp. 343-409. ISSN 0042-0220

Full text not available from this repository. (Request a copy)
Official URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.3138/utlj.61.3.343


This article examines the admissibility of forensic science and medicine in criminal proceedings. In Part ii, we explain how reliability-based admissibility standards in the United States have been unevenly applied to expert evidence in civil and criminal cases and have not prevented wrongful convictions. In Part iii, we review a recent Consultation Paper (and report) issued by the Law Commission of England and Wales. Though focused on the need for ‘sufficiently reliable’ expert opinion evidence, we challenge its contemplation of easier admissibility for experience-based forensic sciences and techniques traditionally admitted. In Part iv we examine the evolving law on the admissibility of expert evidence in Canada. In response, we argue that while front-end reforms to the organization and practice of forensic science and medicine, advocated by the Goudge Inquiry and the American National Academy of Sciences, appear more promising than reliance on the adversary system, the gate-keeping role of trial judges should be strengthened. In the concluding section, we contend that threshold reliability standards should be grounded in criminal-justice system values, emerging empirical insights about the weakness of the adversarial trial and be sensitive to the particular evidence and its use, rather than applied mechanically using simplistic models of science and expertise.

Item Type: Article
Uncontrolled Keywords: wrongful conviction, expert evidence, threshold reliability, National Academy of Sciences, law and science, Goudge
Subjects: M200 Law by Topic
Department: Faculties > Business and Law > Northumbria Law School
Depositing User: Becky Skoyles
Date Deposited: 29 Oct 2013 13:01
Last Modified: 13 Oct 2019 00:38
URI: http://nrl.northumbria.ac.uk/id/eprint/14419

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item


Downloads per month over past year

View more statistics