Use of programme budgeting and marginal analysis to set priorities for local NHS dental services: learning from the north east of England

Holmes, Richard, Steele, Jimmy, Exley, Catherine, Vernazza, Christopher and Donaldson, Cam (2018) Use of programme budgeting and marginal analysis to set priorities for local NHS dental services: learning from the north east of England. Journal of Public Health, 40 (4). e578-e585. ISSN 1741-3842

Text (Programme budgeting article)
Programme budgeting.pdf - Accepted Version

Download (290kB) | Preview
Text (Supplementary files)
Supplementary files.pdf - Accepted Version

Download (1MB) | Preview
Official URL:


Background - Priority setting is necessary where competing demands exceed the finite resources available. The aim of the study was to develop and test a prioritization framework based upon programme budgeting and marginal analysis (PBMA) as a tool to assist National Health Service (NHS) commissioners in their management of resources for local NHS dental services.

Methods - Twenty-seven stakeholders (5 dentists, 8 commissioners and 14 patients) participated in a case-study based in a former NHS commissioning organization in the north of England. Stakeholders modified local decision-making criteria and applied them to a number of different scenarios.

Results - The majority of financial resources for NHS dental services in the commissioning organization studied were allocated to primary care dental practitioners’ contracts in perpetuity, potentially constraining commissioners’ abilities to shift resources. Compiling the programme budget was successful, but organizational flux and difficulties engaging local NHS commissioners significantly impacted upon the marginal analysis phase.

Conclusions - NHS dental practitioners’ contracts resemble budget-silos which do not facilitate local resource reallocation. ‘Context-specific’ factors significantly challenged the successful implementation and impact of PBMA. A local PBMA champion embedded within commissioning organizations should be considered. Participants found visual depiction of the cost-value ratio helpful during their initial priority setting deliberations.

Item Type: Article
Uncontrolled Keywords: dentistry and oral health, economics, health services
Subjects: B900 Others in Subjects allied to Medicine
N300 Finance
Department: Faculties > Health and Life Sciences > Nursing, Midwifery and Health
Depositing User: Becky Skoyles
Date Deposited: 18 May 2018 11:05
Last Modified: 01 Aug 2021 11:47

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item


Downloads per month over past year

View more statistics