Realist Criminology and its Discontents

Winlow, Simon and Hall, Steve (2016) Realist Criminology and its Discontents. International Journal for Crime, Justice and Social Democracy, 5 (3). pp. 80-94. ISSN 2202-7998

Preview

Text 818-Article Text-1975-2-10-20180912.pdf - Published Version Available under License Creative Commons Attribution 4.0. Download (356kB) | Preview

Abstract

Critical criminology must move beyond twentieth-century empiricist and idealist paradigms because the concepts and research programmes influenced by these paradigms are falling into obsolescence. Roger Matthews’ recent work firmly advocates this position and helps to set the ball rolling. Here we argue that Matthews’ attempt to use critical realist thought to move Left Realism towards an advanced position can help to put criminology on a sound new footing. However, before this becomes possible numerous philosophical and theoretical issues must be ironed out. Most importantly, critical criminology must avoid political pragmatism and adopt a more critical stance towards consumer culture’s spectacle. A searching analysis of these issues suggests that, ultimately, criminology is weighed down with obsolete thinking to such an extent that to remain intellectually relevant it must move beyond both Left Realism and Critical Realism to construct a new ultra-realist position.

Actions (login required)

View Item

Downloads