Power, powerlessness, and journal ranking lists: The marginalization of fields of practice

Anderson, Valerie, Elliott, Carole and Callahan, Jamie (2021) Power, powerlessness, and journal ranking lists: The marginalization of fields of practice. Academy of Management Learning & Education, 20 (1). pp. 89-107. ISSN 1537-260X

Preview	Text NRL_41817.pdf - Published Version Available under License Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial No Derivatives 4.0. Download (221kB) | Preview
Preview	Text AMLE Title page + final MS.pdf - Accepted Version Available under License Creative Commons Attribution Non-commercial No Derivatives 4.0. Download (406kB) | Preview

Abstract

This essay contributes a new perspective to debates about journal ranking lists and their effects on the practice of scholarship. Our argument is grounded in practice theory and draws on Bourdieu’s concept of field. We examine the effect of metrics, targets and rankings on Human Resource Development (HRD), a conjunctive field associated with the Management Learning and Education (MLE) field. We examine the ways in which the boundaries of the MLE field are shaped by journal ranking lists and how, irrespective of seniority in the field, scholars simultaneously experience both power and powerlessness as a result of journal ranking processes. We contribute a new perspective on issues of academic practice with consequences for specialized areas of scholarship. We conclude by proposing practical interventions that senior scholars and journal editors can undertake to challenge the undesirable effects of ranking systems and encourage scholarly diversity.

Actions (login required)

View Item

Downloads