Value beyond scientific Validity: Let’s RULE (Reliability, Utility, LEgitimacy)

Wienroth, Matthias (2020) Value beyond scientific Validity: Let’s RULE (Reliability, Utility, LEgitimacy). Journal of Responsible Innovation, 7 (sup1). pp. 92-103. ISSN 2329-9460

RULE_Value_beyond_scientific_validity_2020_10_07.pdf - Accepted Version

Download (283kB) | Preview
Official URL:


My perspective piece contributes to social studies of biometric technologies, and to studies on values and valuation within debates of responsible innovation. I reflect on innovation as social practice where values are temporary settlements of considerations around validity, operability, and social compatibility of socio-technical innovations. As such, I propose a practice-based approach to testing values in new technologies and their respective emerging practice and governance arrangements around Reliability, Utility and LEgitimacy (RULE). These three values combine scientific with operational and social aspects of innovation as centre-points around which deliberative engagement can be facilitated between different societal perspectives, offering the opportunity to develop greater awareness of diverse and at times competing understandings of value. On the case study of forensic genetics – the use of genetic material and data for policing purposes in security and justice contexts – I make the case for multi-perspectival, cross-disciplinary, community-grounded deliberation based on RULE.

Item Type: Article
Uncontrolled Keywords: Forensic Genetics, Legitimacy, Reliability, Utility, Values, Responsible Innovation, Ethics, science and technology studies
Subjects: L300 Sociology
L400 Social Policy
Department: Faculties > Arts, Design and Social Sciences > Social Sciences
Depositing User: Elena Carlaw
Date Deposited: 08 Oct 2020 08:17
Last Modified: 31 Jul 2021 14:05

Actions (login required)

View Item View Item


Downloads per month over past year

View more statistics